Selected by Condé Nast Johansens
(a division of the Condé Nast Group)
THE MOST EXCELLENT INN OF THE AMERICAS

This prestigious Award for Excellence is presented annually to premier worldwide properties that represent the finest standards and value in luxury accommodatioins, and the Excellence Award Winners represent the very best of the best. Votes for the winners are taken from hotel guests, readers of the Condé Nast Johansens Guide, and the Condé Nast Inspection Team. The Baker House 1650 is one of only two B&Bs in the Hamptons listed as recommended by Condé Nast Johansens.
 


OTHER AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS INCLUDE:

BEST OF THE BEST by Dan's Papers every year since 2006
AWARD FOR EXCELLENCE from Architectural Digest (March 2009)
BEST OVERNIGHT ACCOMMODATIONS, Hamptons Cottages & Gardens (Best of Season) BEST INN SHOW, Hamptons Magazine (The Hamptons List)
BEST PLACES TO STAY, Gotham Magazine

It has also received top honors from a wide variety of reviewers, as well as its clientele:


(Click on any publication title to read the full review.)


"...the most luxurious accommodations in town...
the rooms are so deeply comfortable that you
secretly hope for bad weather as an excuse to stay in"



"Each suite has its special pleasures..."



"...one of the country's finest luxury inns..."



"The most distinctive B&B on the East End
is so mind-bogglingly gorgeous that it's hard to
believe anyone is actually allowed to sleep here."



"...recognized as one of the
finest luxury inns in the United States."



"This is my favorite place to stay in the Hamptons."



"...the most luxurious accommodations on the East End...
...a B&B for those looking for a vacation in the lap of luxury."



"Regarded by critics and guests alike as the most
exclusive and luxurious small hotel in the Hamptons..."



"...the most luxurious place in the Hamptons."



"...a paradise of peaceful ease... it's the ultimate place for a grownup's retreat."



"...the place to stay if you want to
feel as if you have not only a house
in the Hamptons, but your own estate."



"...a world-class escape ... Delicious!"



"If it feels more like a home than a hotel,
it's because that sentiment came first..."



"...some of the most luxurious rooms on the East End.
The inviting, oversized bathrooms are comparable
with the finest hotels of Europe."



"...easily the most luxe hotel in the area."



"...this is our preferred choice in East Hampton."


 
ALSO AS SEEN IN....
 

CLICK ON ANY MAGAZINE COVER TO VIEW CONTENTS






  INN OF THE MONTH

THE J. HARPER POOR COTTAGE
[Now The Baker House 1650]
By A.M. Homes

Behind a stucco wall in East Hampton, New York, is a refuge along the lines of an English manor, a wonderfully intimate house, idiosyncratic in this place where high style is defined by the perfectly weathered shingle. The new J. Harper Poor Cottage offers the most luxurious accommodations in town--with the possible exception of the guest rooms of locals Martha Stewart, Calvin Klein, and Steven Spielberg.

The 19th-century structure, renovated by novelist Gary Reiswig and his psychoanalyst wife, Rita, has five guest rooms, all with William Morris wallpaper, fluffy comforters, and big bathtubs. From the front door you can stroll along the town pond, adorned by a swan so stunningly large as to seem mythic, then pass some of the most luscious landscaping in America on your way to the sea. Or you might linger in the cottage's formal English garden, where tiny boxwood leaves tremble in the breeze. Going to sleep, you imagine returning in the off-season to spend hours reading before a fire. The rooms are so deeply comfortable that you secretly hope for bad weather as an excuse to stay in.



HAUTE HAMPTONS
By John Cantrell

At last, visitors to the Hamptons don't have to rent a $30,000-per-month beach house or else risk settling for less -- much less -- at some "cheap" (but still overpriced) motel. The J. Harper Poor Cottage in East Hampton offers the kind of plush overnight accommodations that you'd expect to find in an area famous for its residential real estate; the five-room inn is poor in name only. Set in an Arts and Crafts-style mansion on Main Street, it offers views of East Hampton's picture perfect town pond and green from the front, while back windows give onto a formal garden and a pergola crowned by a wisteria vine two centuries old. Inside, owners Gary and Rita Reiswig and designer Gary Jay Paul echo both the house's architecture and its landscaping using an abundance of color and comfort, of art and craft. The twining greenery of the Great Room's William Morris-upholstered armchairs boldly plays against a blue-and-white tiled fireplace. There's a grand piano, plus ample books and reading lamps, but the mood is more comfy than stuffy. Upstairs the pale-green theme reaches full bloom on the walls of the guest suites, where Morris' botanical fabrics create the ideal backdrop for a gentle getaway. Each suite has its special pleasures--exposed beams and primitive-style antique wall paneling, a king-size bed close by a fireplace, a simple claw-foot tub--so you'll be as comfortable here as you are in your own spread on Lily Pond Lane.... There is a three-night minimum during July and August if your stay includes a Saturday night.



Oceanside Colonies Where the Elite Meet and Greet

THE HAMPTONS
Long Island, New York

...the Baker House 1650, a glorious English manor house converted to one of the country's finest luxury inns with five sumptuous rooms, an English garden, and the most coveted guest amenity of all—beach parking permits.



THE J. HARPER POOR COTTAGE
[Now The Baker House 1650]

The most distinctive B&B on the East End is so mind-bogglingly gorgeous that it's hard to believe anyone is actually allowed to sleep here. The living room is papered with golden lilies; the formal gardens in back are surrounded by 200-year-old wisteria; and the beamed ceilings and paneled doors in some rooms are remnants of the structures that occupied this site in the 16th and 17th centuries. All of these elements have been beautifully incorporated into the decor of the current building, a large, Arts-and-Crafts-style manor.



Heavenly and Historic—The Baker House 1650

   The magnificently refurbished Baker House 1650 (formerly the J.Harper Poor Cottage) in East Hampton has been recognized as one of the finest luxury inns in the United States. It was named "Inn of the Month" by Travel and Leisure magazine, and Town and Country said the cottage "offers the kind of plush accommodations that you'd expect to find in an area famous for its residential real estate." Time Out New York said "the most distinctive B&B on the East End is so mind-bogglingly gorgeous that it's hard to believe anyone is actually allowed to sleep here."
   HISTORY
   The Baker House, one of the oldest continuously occupied structures in the United States, dates back to the earliest settlers of the Village of East Hampton. The house, first constructed in 1648 by a sea captain, Daniel Howe, was sold to Thomas Baker in 1650. Thomas Baker, one of the Town's original founders, turned the house into Baker's Tavern. The early structure served many other functions in the newly settled area, including town meeting hall, community center, and as the first location of religious services.
   Joseph Greenleaf Thorp, a prominent turn-of-the-century architect with ties to the English Arts and Crafts Movement, was employed to dramatically expand the house in the Elizabethan style that was his signature, coinciding with a period of Anglophilia, which prompted an attempt to change the Town name back to its original Maidstone. The renovation concluded in 1917, when the shingled house was wrapped in stucco, completing the transformation of an American Colonial house with hand-hewn beams into an expansive English manor of many rooms and refinements.
   THE GUESTROOMS
   Each bedroom is beautifully decorated, with individually controlled central air conditioning and heat, Bartech minibar, in-room security safe, televisions with full cable services and DVD, top-of-the-line Bose radios and CD players, multiple telephone lines, and wireless Internet access. Most of the rooms have wood-burning fireplaces, whirlpools and flat screen televisions. Bathrooms are lavish, with amenities by L'Occitane and bathrobes by Mascioni.
   BREAKFAST, ETC.
   Each morning begins with a sumptuous breakfast served in the garden-side breakfast room, in the garden itself during spring, summer and fall, or before a wood burning fire in winter, from 8:30 a.m. to 10:30 a.m. You can also opt for continental breakfast in your own room, delivered with your choice of morning paper. Local organic produce and farm products are used wherever possible. There are outside tables for eating, reading, or lounging, and drinks are served from a well-stocked bar including a selection of wines by the glass, bottle, and half-bottle.
   SPECIAL EVENTS
   The Baker House is available for special events including weddings, private parties, and photo shoots. Many memorable weddings have been held in the house and gardens, starting with the wedding of J. Harper Poor's daughter, Mildred, in 1915, for which a private train from Pennsylvania Station was arranged to bring some of the most distinguished families of the time to East Hampton for the occasion. The original wedding invitation and newspaper announcement of the event still hang in the lobby of The Baker House and the bride's preserved Gift Book makes fascinating reading.
   THE BAKER SPA
   The last thing one would expect in a historic 1648 house is a state-of-the-art spa facility, but that is what one finds on descending the paneled staircase leading to the lower level. An endless pool, spa tub, sauna, steam shower, and change room comprise the spa and although it is modern in every aspect, builder/designer David Tosher and design consultant Gary Jay Paul have created a room that seems to always have been there. The opportunity for guests to reserve the spa privately for treatments and purification provides unparalleled luxury for an inn of this size.
   THE GARDENS & POOL
   Planted in evergreens, flowering perennials and blooming shrubs, the informal gardens cover nearly a full acre. Its paths wind past border plantings that include herbs whose scents echo those of the aromatic oils used in the spa. The sweeping lawn and beautiful English gardens have been featured in many books and magazines. Outdoor terraces, a 200-year-old wisteria, and vine-covered garden walls transport the guests to a manor house in France of the English countryside. A new outdoor infinity-edge pool has been added for guests with teak chaises for sunning. In the summer, guests receive coveted East Hampton Village beach parking passes, as well as beach towels, umbrellas and chairs.



Baker House 1650
The Hamptons

SPECIAL OCCASION


This is my favorite place to stay in the Hamptons. As one guest remarked on my last visit, the Baker House reminded them of an elegant farmhouse in which they had stayed in Provence.

Designed in 1910 from a 1648 farmhouse, this architectural marvel is a stunning property and unlike anything you have experienced before. Beautifully decorated in period antiques and comfortable furniture, the public rooms include a wood paneled reading room with a fireplace and a living room, also with a massive fireplace, with 3 separate sitting areas. One overlooks the rear gardens, one is in front of the fireplace and one surrounds an antique piano, a John Broadwood & Sons, from London. There are cushioned window seats throughout the cottage and in many of the rooms.

The low, beamed ceiling breakfast room with French doors to the patio also has a bar and a couch and chair fronting a wood stove. Guests gather there at cocktail hour and help themselves to an honor bar. Have what you like and write it down on a pad. Liquor, beer, wine champagne and soft drinks and snacks are avaiable 24 hours a day.

In 2001 a wonderful spa was added on the lower level. The music filled oasis is a soothing and tranquil respite from the drinking and dining pleasures of your weekend. The slate floor, brick walled facility has a steam room, sauna, exercise equipment and a swim-in-place lap pool. Thick terry robes are provided and massages can be arranged by management.

There are only 5 bedrooms and with the exception of Room #15, which has twin beds, any one will do fine. My two favorites, however, are Room #12, a huge room overlooking the village green, with a king sized bed, love seat and ottoman, fireplace and Jacuzzi tub and Room #14, also overlooking the green, with dark walls, beamed ceilings, a queen bed, fireplace and claw footed tub. Other amenities include television, a sound machine, down comforters, big thick towels and Gilchrist & Soames toiletries.

Coffee, juice, cereal and homemade muffins, fresh from the oven and newspapers are available at 7:30am in the breakfast room or on the patio. A full breakfast is served at 8:30am.





Rest Assured at
East Hampton B&Bs

By Kathryn G. Menu

The Baker House 1650, located on Main Street, offers some of the most luxurious accommodations on the East End. It has five individually decorated rooms with spectacular views overlooking either the English gardens toward the rear of the property or the Village Green in front.

Originally built in 1648, the Baker House was re-created by Gary and Rita Reiswig who renovated the building in 1996. East Hampton and Manhattan residents Antonella and Bob Rosen took the reins last year, and have sculpted the Reiswigs' successful venture into a retreat that features some of the finest accommodations on the East End.

Country-inspired decor coupled with wood burning fireplaces and flat screen TVs may leave summer guests longing for winter. The generously sized bathrooms, many with spa tubs, feature L'Occitane bath products and robes by Mascioni, further emphasizing that the establishment pays attention to every detail.

Breakfast at the Baker House 1650 is equally extraordinary, emphasizing local, organic products and featuring homemade fare like lemon pancakes and apple tarte tatin. Guests can enjoy these culinary treats in the English garden, nearly and acre of flowers, evergreens, herbs, a lush lawn and climbing vines including a 200-year-old wisteria. The garden's centerpiece is an infinity pool, surrounded by teak lounge chairs.

The spa, completed in 2000, offers guests unusual luxuries for a B&B like a lap pool, and massage, facial and purification treatments. For beach-going guests, the Baker House 1650 provides the much in demand but short in supply parking permits to all the village beaches, as well as towels, beach chairs and umbrellas.

Within walking distance to Main Beach and the village shopping district, and with manager Kathy McCormack and assistant manager Heather McCormack fulfilling most every whim, the Baker House 1650 is a B&B for those looking for a vacation in the lap of luxury.





The Baker House 1650, East Hampton, NY

Regarded by critics and guests alike as the most exclusive and luxurious small hotel in the Hamptons, The Baker House 1650 has a distinctive European fell with ivy-covered walls and beautiful formal English gardens. Less expected are state-of-the-art amenities such as flat-screen TVs, wireless Internet, two swimming pools (one indoors and one infinity-edge outdoors), and The Baker Spa, providing unparalleled luxury.



THE J. HARPER POOR COTTAGE
[Now The Baker House 1650]

The elegance of an English country cottage is captured in both the grand mansion and the manicured gardens at East Hampton's J. Harper Poor Cottage. The apple green decor is accented with arts- and-crafts-style William Morris fabrics and wallpaper, an imposing blue-and-white tiled fireplace in the spacious living room, and exposed rough-hewn beams from the original house, built around 1720.

Yet despite surroundings that instantly carry guests back to a calmer, more romantic era, owners Gary and Rita Reiswig offer the same impeccable service of a well-run hotel as well as all the modem amenities. The five bedrooms not only have fireplaces in all but one; each includes phones, television with cable and VCRs, and brand new bathrooms with separate showers and bathtubs.

The delightful garden is more than the ideal place for lingering over the full breakfast that's served buffet-style; periodically the Reiswigs open it to the public as an outdoor sculpture gallery. This fall's exhibit of marble nudes runs into early October. Once the owners of East Hampton's Maidstone Arms, the Reiswigs acquired the Poor Cottage two years ago, wanting to turn it into "the most luxurious place in the Hamptons." Maintaining the house's original details -- like the carved wooden door-lintel angel in front and the antique birdbath in the garden in back -- have helped them accomplish their goal.



Havens In The Hamptons

Hit these spas by the sea before the summer crowds

In the Hamptons, exfoliation, aromatherapy, and seaview pedicures are the favored rites of spring. If you can sneak away for the weekend before the post-Memorial Day madness, here are some tips to help you celebrate winter's end with a beachside renewal of body and spirit.

EAST HAMPTON: THE J. HARPER POOR COTTAGE
[Now the Baker House 1650]

Guardian spirits carved above the door at the J. Harper Poor Cottage welcome you into a paradise of peaceful ease. Dating back to an astonishing 1648, "The Cottage," later restyled as an arts and craft mansion, wears its history with grace. Spring-inspired William Morris fabrics, an ancient wisteria trellis festooning the garden, and in-room wood-burning fireplaces whisper a sense of elegance and ease.

The Cottage is the only inn in East Hampton where you can enjoy spa facilities without leaving the premises. After breakfast, descend the stairs to the stone-tiled spa room, where a serene indoor pool invites you to take a dip. The fitness-focused will find exercise equipment, but the best thing about the spa is that it can be rented out for a private massage for individuals or couples. As relaxing music soothes your ears, you'll be rubbed by the practiced hands of an expert like Alexis Philip, who teaches at Manhattan's Swedish Institute.

When it's time to tear yourself away, East Hampton offers plenty of shopping and antiquing opportunities. A good dinner bet is Bamboo Restaurant and Sushi Lounge, offering fresh and imaginative pan-Asian dishes that won't compromise your low-carb diet.



     
Not really a cottage and certainly not poor, this could be the place to stay if you want to feel as if you have not only a house in the Hamptons, but your own estate. Tucked discreetly behind a stucco wall diagonally across from East Hampton's town pond it was opened a few yews ago by the former owners of the nearby Maidstone Arms. The house was designed in 1910 by Arts and Crafts architect Joseph Greenleaf Thorp and incorporated an older 1648 farmhouse. Now it looks like an elegant but comfy country manor with all the amenities of a luxury hotel. Though it has only five rooms, there is a new subterranean spa, only for guests, with one of those swim-in-place resistance lap pools and private massage rooms.


     


Escape
     FROM  New York
[by Jason Oliver Nixon]

Peruvian tour de force Antonella Bertello-Rosen and her husband, Bob, stunningly revamped the former J.Harper Poor Cottage in East Hampton in 2005, transforming the 1648 Tudor-style building into a world-class escape with five ultraluxe guest rooms. Sure, the location is perfection, just minutes from East Hampton shopping and dining, but once you check in, we predict you may choose never to venture farther afield—on our last visit, we honestly never shed our bathrobes.

Step inside and enter a world of extreme comfort and impeccable taste thanks to arts-and-crafts sensibilities tempered with rich textures and overstuffed furnishings. Our favorite rooms is the Maidstone, outfitted with William Morris wallpaper and housing a heavenly sleigh bed, wood-burning fireplace, decadent spa tub, and bay windows overlooking historic Mulford Farm and Main Street. We're also mad for the Gardiner Suite, which opens onto the inn's amazing garden with its 200-year-old wisteria vine, pergola, and intimate swimming pool.

Head downstairs and sip a glass of wine at the honor-system bar (drink as you please and keep track yourself), read a book in the library, or visit the beautifully designed basement with its lap pool, sauna, steam shower, and treatment room where guests might partake of numerous massages, facials, and body polishes. Delicious!



     
It may seem affected to call a house of this size a cottage, but that's the feeling evoked by its tasteful, restrained restoration. Owners and architects past and present seem to have worked in collusion with a singular vision. Suiting the house perfectly is the English country decorating scheme -- easy furniture, a soft palette, and William Morris-designed papers and fabrics. The J. Harper Poor Cottage in East Hampton, New York, is the house Gary and Rita Reiswig had wanted to own for years. ...They got the Poor Cottage in 1996, planning renovations that would allow them to enjoy the house, create a separate owners' suite, and open five bedrooms as a luxury hostelry. If it feels more like a home than a hotel, it's because that sentiment came first...


     
JODI'S FAVORITES

The following are places that I often recommend to friends looking for luxury accommodations, family spots, bargains and quintessential Hamptons getaways.

The J. Harper Poor Cottage
181 Main Street, East Hampton

Walking into the J. Harper Poor Cottage you feel as if you've walked into an Old English manor. A perfectly manicured terrace and elegant sitting room welcome you into this beautifully decorated, pristine hotel which has some of the most luxurious rooms on the East End. The inviting, oversized bathrooms are comparable with the finest hotels of Europe. Be prepared to spend some time in your room. But call well in advance - they're often booked by those in the know before the summer season even begins.



     
This five room inn, an early-20th-century expansion of a 17th-century farmhouse, is easily the most luxe hotel in the area. The rooms are large and filled with a mix of antiques and comfy chairs... And a rarity for a hotel this size: There's a small spa that can be retained for private use, with massages or swimming in the miniature pool whose current mimics the waves of the ocean.


     
Located on the same strip as Maidstone Arms, further along Main Street, this charming 5-bedroom country-house has a pretty garden and pool, as well as an indoor pool and spa facilities. On balance this is our preferred choice in East Hampton.



The Mid-Atlantic's Best Bed & Breakfasts
Romantic Retreats
Havens in The Hamptons
Recommended Bed and Breakfasts, Mid-Atlantic States
The Hamptons Before the Crowds
Town & Country





Web site designed and maintained by
The Hamptons Web, a subsidiary of Sagal Computer Systems.
(c) Copyright 2005 The Baker House 1650, All Rights Reserved